Savingforcollege.com
Page 1 of 1 1
Topic Options
#43411 - 05/27/08 12:33 PM Criteria for selecting which 529 plan to liquidate
seshadri
Registered: 08/31/03
Posts: 8
I have 3 kids, two starting college in Fall and the third in 2012. I have PA TAP prepaid guaranteed savings plan for all three, a generic 529 in Vanguard, and also an independent 529 account with prepaid credits. All have had money in them long enough for them to be withdrawn. My questions:
1) I'm told there is no problem moving money amongst the kids - eg. the independent 529 beneficiary isn't going to one the member colleges, but my son is. Is this really true - are there no adverse consequences to moving it to another child?
2) How do I decide which funds to begin depleting. eg. in the uncertain stock market, does it make more sense to deplete the Vanguard funds which are now heavily in bonds and rely on making the "gains" by holding on to prepaid credits which I'm assuming will continue to rise as they have. Or can you suggest other areas to look at before I start liquidating the funds.
I also need to find out some tax implications - PA gives a state tax deduction on contributions up to $12/24K. I need to find out, for example, if deductions because of contributions to kid A last year will be nullified if I were to move that money this year to kid B. Thanks.
Thanks.

Top
#43412 - 05/27/08 01:05 PM Re: Criteria for selecting which 529 plan to liquidate [Re: seshadri]
Drew
Registered: 01/09/00
Posts: 2478
1. You can move funds about on the same generation with no gift tax issues
1.1 No clue about what the independen tplans say about mobility.

2.At least for now I see the imputed return on PA GSP as outperforming many fund type 529s and if you pay atention to fund the GSP in summer you get about a 6% instant uptick in tuition equivalent--match that with a fund! Hey, I might even roll marginal plans over to a GSP, hey, even a flip of Vanguard to GSP may produce an uptick--and 6% of a 50,000 plan is free if done right......
3. No actually PA allows for state tax deductions up to the FULL total taxable income of both parents or anyone else making contribution, up to $12,000 per plan--so if you had 12 members of the family you could set up 12 plans--perhaps 24 if married and spouse had income.....in short you can pack the whole family tree.
4.I do not see where PA has a recapture of its 3.07% income tax and besides a transfer is not a contribution.
4.1 Somebody else asked essentially if they could recycle older 529s so as to capture the newer PA Income tax benefits--I don't think that is intended---but I didn't read fine print of actual law--sometime PA writes some daffy stuff--but in my book a stretch is ok but a transfer is not a contribution.
_________________________
Drew

Top
Page 1 of 1 1


Moderator:  Joe Hurley 
Hop to:

Bankrate.com ®, Copyright © 2008 Bankrate, Inc., All Rights Reserved, Terms of Use.